A friend of mine recently achieved top-secret government clearance as a part of the military and I was decidedly miffed. It was one of those deals in which agents overhaul your entire past, dig up childhood friends and hold interviews with your current contacts.
“Why didn’t they ask me?” I teased. “I am the gossip queen and I have all kinds of dirt on you!”
“Well, I didn’t know you that well before this summer,” he said. “And besides, I was trying to protect you. I mean, look at the kind of literature you’re reading.” He gestured to my array of books stacked in front of our study session. A quick review of the titles revealed, “In Defense of Socialism,” “Selected Speeches by Fidel Castro,” and “The Che Guevara Reader.”
“They’re for my Cuban Revolution class,” I replied, defensively.
“Exactly,” he said. “You’d have a better shot if it was for your ‘Anti-Cuban Revolution’ class.”
“Well, how do you know I wasn’t going to burn them when the semester’s over?” I challenged.
“Unlikely,” he said. “Let’s face it, our friendship is dangerous.”
But is it really? What’s the big deal about Cuba anyway? Does anyone even remember or do we just continue to spit out the slandering rhetoric that we’ve been spoon fed since birth? I am inclined to believe the latter.
OK, so there was a time when Cuba was a viable threat to our nation, both in terms of its proximity and its Communist ideology in the dawn of the Cold War, but that was ages ago. Isn’t it kind of childish to hold grudges? Let me put it to you this way: say you were in a long-term relationship with a guy for most of your college career and during that time, you two were inseparable. You invested an ample amount of money, time and energy into your coexistence in hopes that it would lead to marriage. Yet one day, he inexplicably turned and left you for some socialist slut. Naturally, you would be heartbroken for a long time; but forty years? I don’t think so.
Eventually, you would come to terms with the fact that he had a change of heart and you would move on. Perhaps you could even be friends. Maybe you would realize that the relationship hadn’t been exactly perfect and that you were much more controlling and manipulative than you had thought. Everybody has been young and everybody has made mistakes. It doesn’t make sense to make him, all of his friends and family, and the generations to come, pay for the unfortunate fallout — especially if his family has already suffered numerous hardships, such as three consecutive hurricanes that ravaged their homeland.
Sure, you could offer him aid money, but that would seem kind of cheap. If you continue to keep up the embargo and the international invective of calling him a terrorist, but slip him money on the side, that’s no apology — that’s hypocrisy. You’re best friends with China and he sleeps with that socialist slut as well.
Maybe you think it’s wrong to reduce international foreign policy to a human anecdote, but I don’t. At the end of the day, that’s what it all comes back to. We’re all humans. We’re capable of compassion just as much as we’re inclined to make mistakes. For the sake of humanity, I hope an older, wiser — dare I say darker-toned and skinnier — elder will shed some fresh perspective on this petty and archaic relationship vendetta. Then I can go back to reading my books in peace.
Ashley Dresser welcomes comments at adresser@mndaily.com.
Comments
Your mother...
... is like Karl Marx's theory of socioeconomics: every worker gets a share!
Stay in College
You clearly ought to stay in college until you learn something of substance. Your professor should be ashamed of himself or herself. Any particular reason that this two-bit, clearly tenth rate Cuban Revolution class doesn't have Against All Hope as required reading? I'm guessing it is because your prof is more interested in brainwashing you and hey, mission accomplished. Why do thousands of people flee Cuba if it has any redeming qualities. Clearly people would not risk their lives unless things were pretty terrible. But everyone makes mistakes, right? Who cares about thousands imprisioned and tortured in Cuba... as long as it is in the past (it is in the past right)?
On that note I anxiously await your next letter defending President Bush along similar grounds.
"Tenth rate"
1) The U's PoliSci department has been ranked nationally in the top 15 for years, so it is easily first rate. Too bad it's still PoliSci and not something you can get a decent job with.
2) It's probably bad in Cuba because the country is so economically isolated. If we blockaded L.A., everyone would try to escape - especially Kurt Russell.
Reading For Content
You should also stay in college for a while.
1)I called the class tenth rate, not the department. Clearly an even highly regarded PoliSci Department can occasionally lay an egg of a class. I used the information provided to determine that this.
2) I reject your argument that conditions in Cuba are bad because they are economically isolated. I propose (and thousands of former Cubans would agree) that Cuba is isolated because the government is cruel and inhumane to the populace.
Amendment
"...to determine that this." should read: "to determine that this is the case.
I propose a constitutional
I propose a constitutional amendment to ban comment amendments on this page! Let's call it "Proposition WOLVERIIIIINES!!!"
1) You used the information
1) You used the information provided? You mean the limited information provided? A paragraph designed for a purpose other than to fully describe the content of a class is a poor source of information on said class. The remainder of the column was essentially all the opinion of the author - an opinion which may nor may not be reflective of the course content. The class might have been all about the evils of Castro, for all you know.
2) If Cuba is so cruel and inhumane, why do people still live there? Every last Cuban is a boat trip away from another country. I bet the residents outnumber those who left by at least 2 to 1. Also, if the country is so cruel and inhumane, why do Cubans keep participating in the cruel and inhumane treatment of each other? Why haven't they just stopped? Why hasn't someone popped Castro? Why do they have socialized medicine?
Information
1) Yes I used the limited information provided to make a rational argument that the class is probably poorly run and biased. No one has stood up to defend the class, only to attack the argument. That is pretty pathetic.
2) I'll answer in order:
2a: The government keeps them there.
2bsub1: (nice multi-part question): I'll bet the number who left versus who haven't left is a heck of a lot higher than 2:1 (2:1 would be crazy, the whole island would have to be on fire) but the point is that leaving is difficult, dangerous, and illegal and people still do it in huge numbers.
2bsub2: I assume you are arguing that people can never be cruel or inhumane to others in their own country please let the people in Rwanda, Iraq, and countless other places know that. Obviously many people will choose to be cruel out of fear or because it brings some privledges.
3) It turns out that killing Castro is hard. People have tried. (Bay of Pigs anyone)?
4) They have socialized healthcare because they are communists. The fact that people can get free care does not in and of itself prove anything. I'm not saying anything one way or the other on the issue of universal healthcare, it just doesn't excuse a country.
Alumi Wins
Anonymous, you should probably just give up. You're getting killed here.
Alumni wins?
No, he doesn't. He's going to die first. Booyah!
Here's What Amnesty International has to Say About Cuba
http://www.amnesty.org/en/ai_search?keywords=Cuba&op=Search&form_id=sear...
Why would anyone care what
Why would anyone care what these tea-baggers think? They're a bunch of softies!
Post new comment